Shiny Moon Cafe
4164 Main Street • Fish Creek WI
About Shiny Moon Cafe
Our mission at Shiny Moon Cafe is to provide a vibrant, community minded cafe in Door County. Much like what we created at Door County Brewing Co., our goal is to provide the best quality products with an inviting setting and treat customers and staff as we would family ensuring Shiny Moon Cafe to become a year round destination and gathering place for our community.
Shiny Moon Cafe is a specialty coffee house and cafe owned and operated by Angie and John McMahon and is located in downtown Fish Creek at 4164 Main Street just above the Fish Creek Market. We offer a unique line-up of seasonal Single Origin Drip Coffees, Single Origin Cold Brews and Espresso. Our coffee is rich in flavor and the espresso is a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity that functions well in milk drinks. In addition to our coffees, we serve breakfast and lunch items including breakfast biscuit sandwiches, skillets, in house made artisanal lunch sandwiches, soups, pastries, baked goods, small deserts and cookies.
Shiny Moon is committed to sustainable agriculture and supporting local farmers, bakers and cheese makers and include: Hidden Acres Farm, Cold Climate Farms, Mighty Wind Farms, Door County Creamery, Cultured and Avery Acres.
The cafe itself has an airy, relaxing charm and draws on Door County’s rich cultural arts scene by highlighting local artists work.
From the Press
Eater ChicagoNaomi Waxman Jun 17, 2021
“Shiny Moon Cafe, a newish venture from prolific area entrepreneur Angie McMahon (Door County Brewing Co., Hacienda Beer Co.), is already cultivating a following with comforting fare like quiche du jour, Eggs in Purgatory, and duck confit hash with banana peppers. Find it on the second floor of the Fish Creek Market"
Andrew Kleidon, Peninsula Pulse – August 13th, 2021
"If you feel at home working on a laptop in a metropolitan cafe or just want to impress a friend who’s looking for the cool, new spot, Shiny Moon Cafe, 4164 Main St. in Fish Creek, is checking all the boxes"
"The egg biscuit sandwiches were simply phenomenal. I got the Kalua pork egg biscuit. The biscuit itself was immensely flavorful and the pork was surprisingly juicy. Our whole group left fully satisfied and eager to return."